PS5 DualSense vs Xbox Series X Controller: A Guide to Picking the Right Controller
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
A major factor when picking a new console is the controller, as it connects you to the gaming experience. Both Xbox and Sony have refined their controller designs over the years, but this time around, some interesting choices were made. In this article, I will try to help you decide which is better the PS5 DualSense or the Xbox Series X controller, as well as give my own opinion. This article is part of a series of articles to determine which is better PS5 or Xbox.
Xbox vs. Sony Controllers
The DualSense has numerous new features, while the Xbox Series X controller has only minor differences from its predecessor. So, if the input device will be the deciding factor between consoles, which one should you choose?
DualShock vs. DualSense
Historically, Sony named their controllers “DualShock,” with versions 1 through 4 corresponding to each console generation. However, the new controller is so different that they opted for a new name: DualSense. The DualSense has more features than all previous Sony controllers and the Xbox Series X controller, including:
- Haptic feedback: A more advanced rumble feature
- Adaptive triggers: Force feedback on the triggers that corresponds to in-game actions
- Built-in microphone and mute button
- Speaker: Can be both a cool and occasionally annoying feature
DualShock 4 Wireless Controller for PlayStation 4 - Midnight Blue
$59.99
A Comparison of Xbox Series X and DualSense Controllers
DualSense Controller Features
The DualSense controller has a touch bar similar to the PS4 controller, a built-in accelerometer, and a gyroscope for motion sensing. It’s packed with advanced technology, explaining the $70 price tag. Some features include:
- Touch bar
- Accelerometer and gyroscope for motion sensing
- Haptic feedback
- Adaptive triggers
- Built-in microphone and mute button
- Speaker
Playstation DualSense Wireless Controller
Xbox Series X Controller
The Xbox Series X controller is similar to the previous generation, with a slightly smaller size and a new hybrid D-pad design. Notable features include:
- Slightly smaller size
- New hybrid D-pad design
- Dedicated share button
- Rumble built into the triggers
- Dynamic Latency Input for reduced controller input latency
Xbox Core Wireless Controller – Robot White
Summary
The DualSense controller boasts more advanced features than its Xbox Series X counterpart, such as haptic feedback and adaptive triggers. Meanwhile, the Xbox Series X controller maintains a familiar design with the addition of a new D-pad and a focus on reducing input latency.
Latency Testing of Xbox Series X and DualSense Controllers
Testing Methodology
To test latency, I used a 60 Hz monitor and filmed the tests at 120 frames per second. Afterward, I placed the footage in a 24 frames per second timeline and counted the frames. While not the most scientific approach, it is effective with the available resources.
Test Results
The Xbox controller displayed faster response times when hardwired, which is in line with expectations. However, the DualSense controller was significantly faster, even when hardwired. Determining the precise moment when the triggers were fully pressed was challenging, but since the DualSense triggers have a longer travel, it should have favored the Xbox controller. Surprisingly, it did not.
Important Note: A more scientific test is recommended for conclusive results. If latency is a significant factor for you, consider not solely relying on Xbox’s marketing claims and conducting additional research.
Shared Features Between Controllers
Despite their differences, both the Xbox Series X and DualSense controllers share numerous similarities:
- They have the same number of buttons
- Both controllers feature built-in three-ring headphone jacks, which are useful for games that require communication
- They have textured backside grips for a premium feel and enhanced comfort
- USB-C connectivity is used for charging and connecting
The Xbox controller is designed to have lower latency when plugged directly into the console. If you play close to your console, it might be worth considering keeping the controller plugged in all the time.
Controller Battery and Compatibility: DualSense vs Xbox Series X
Battery Considerations
DualSense Controller
- The DualSense features a built-in battery, which may become a concern as the battery deteriorates over time, rendering the controller unusable.
Xbox Series X Controller
- Priced at $60, the Xbox Series X controller is $10 cheaper than the DualSense.
- It requires AA batteries or a separately purchased Play and Charge Kit, which some may find inconvenient.
- Ideally, the controller should include a rechargeable battery with the option to use AA batteries if desired.
Compatibility Across Console Generations
Microsoft emphasizes that their controllers are compatible across console generations. For instance, Xbox One controllers work on the Xbox Series X, and vice versa.
Docking Stations and Battery Covers
If you own an Xbox One controller, you may have purchased a docking station for charging. While these stations are available in various colors and designs, they may not be fully compatible with the Xbox Series X controller due to slight differences in the battery cover. To use the charging station with the new controller, you’ll need to purchase an additional back plate that comes with another rechargeable battery.
Controller Design and Comfort: DualSense vs Xbox Series X
DualSense Controller
- The DualSense feels larger compared to the Xbox controller.
- The split D-pad is an improvement over previous designs, with a more comfortable feel.
- Despite its size, the DualSense is extremely comfortable, even for those more accustomed to Xbox controllers.
Xbox Series X Controller
- Known for their larger designs, Xbox controllers feature canted thumbsticks.
- The Xbox Series X controller has shorter triggers compared to the DualSense.
Comfort and Adaptability
While the Xbox Series X controller has been the go-to choice for many due to its design and comfort, the DualSense controller offers a surprisingly comfortable experience. Those transitioning from the Xbox One controller to the DualSense may find it easy to adapt, even when playing fast-paced games like Call of Duty. On paper, the DualSense’s features make it a superior controller overall in terms of design and comfort.
The Future of DualSense Controller Features
Experiencing DualSense’s Tech in Games
Astro’s Playroom, a free game that comes with the PlayStation 5, is a great example of how the DualSense controller’s features can be utilized by developers. This game effectively showcases the controller’s potential and enhances the gaming experience.
DualSense Features in Other Games
Some current games, such as Call of Duty and NBA 2K21, have already started using the DualSense controller’s features:
- In Call of Duty, different force feedback on the triggers corresponds to various weapons.
- In NBA 2K21, triggers provide resistance when a player gets fatigued, indicating their level of exhaustion.
Uncertainty of Future Implementation
While the DualSense’s features have the potential to offer unique gaming experiences, it is uncertain whether developers will continue to utilize these features in the long term. The current adoption could be due to the novelty of the technology, and it remains to be seen if it will become a standard in future game developments.
DualSense Controller: Microphone, Speaker, and Haptic Feedback
The DualSense controller’s built-in microphone is a convenient feature, but its default setting is “on,” which might not be ideal for all users. Similarly, the PlayStation camera mic also defaults to “on.” It would be better if users had to opt-in for these features.
The controller’s speaker works well in games like Astro’s Playroom, where it combines with haptic feedback to create an immersive experience with audio cues. However, in games like Modern Warfare, the speaker defaults to playing voice chat from teammates, which can be annoying.
Haptic Feedback Comparison
Sony’s haptic feedback technology in the DualSense controller isn’t a significant improvement over Nintendo’s HD Rumble. While it was marketed as a groundbreaking feature, it is, at best, on par with HD Rumble. Those who have experienced One Two Switch on the Nintendo Switch can attest to this.
The PlayStation 5 controller’s haptic feedback is certainly better than traditional rumble, but it doesn’t quite reach the level of feeling balls rolling around or ice shaking in a glass, as seen with HD Rumble. Nonetheless, the DualSense controller’s haptic feedback is still a high-quality feature.
Xbox Series X Controller
The Xbox Series X controller remains largely unchanged from its predecessor, with only a slightly smaller design. The most notable difference is the new hybrid-style D-pad, which offers a comfortable and satisfying experience despite initial scepticism. A dedicated share button, essential in the age of social media, makes it easy to share captured photos and videos through the Xbox app.
Similarities Between Controllers
Both the Xbox Series X and DualSense controllers have many shared features. They have a similar button layout, a built-in three-ring headphone jack for in-game communication, and textured backsides that, while not providing a tactical advantage, offer a premium feel. Both controllers now use USB-C for connectivity and charging.
Comparing Haptic Feedback and Compatibility with Nintendo Switch and PC
Haptic Feedback Comparison
Despite the hype surrounding the DualSense controller’s haptic feedback, it isn’t better than Nintendo’s HD Rumble. At best, it’s on par with it. Although the PS5 controller offers an improved experience compared to standard rumble, it doesn’t quite reach the level of feeling balls rolling around the controller or ice shaking in a glass like HD Rumble. However, the rumble in the DualSense is still impressive.
Compatibility with Nintendo Switch and PC
With an 8BitDo adapter, both the DualSense and Xbox Series X controllers can be used on a Nintendo Switch. Both controllers also connect to computers without issue. However, the Xbox controller provides more native compatibility with PC games and applications. If PC integration is important, the Xbox controller may be a better choice, as PC developers are unlikely to utilize the advanced features of the DualSense.
Xbox Series X vs PlayStation 5 DualSense Controllers: A Summary
Both the Xbox Series X and PlayStation 5 DualSense controllers have their own advantages and are comfortable to use. The author has a preference for the Xbox controller due to familiarity but acknowledges that they could adapt to the DualSense easily.
Navigating menus across different consoles like Xbox, PlayStation, and Nintendo can be challenging due to varying button layouts. While the DualSense offers more features such as haptic feedback, the Xbox controller still delivers solid performance and comfort.
The author advises against choosing a console based solely on the controller, as there are other factors to consider, like the games available on each platform. They believe that console wars are pointless and recommend gamers to choose their preferred console based on the games they want to play.
In conclusion, there is no definitive winner between the two controllers.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates.
